A Pit Lane Power Play
Picture this; It’s a sunny afternoon at a major motorsports event. The atmosphere is buzzing with excitement and anticipation. In the pit lane garage, Sarah is gearing up to discuss the race strategy with her team. She’s armed with data and a solid plan.
Characters:
Sarah – Female race engineer
Mike – Male team leader
Tom – Male mechanic
Alex – Male data analyst
John – Male team owner (observing from a distance)
The Scenario
Mike: “Alright team, we need to discuss our pit stop strategy for the upcoming race.”
Sarah: “I’ve analysed the data from our last few races. I think we should consider a two-stop strategy instead of three. It could save us crucial seconds…”
Tom (interrupting): “Come on, Sarah. Leave the strategy to the guys who’ve been doing it for years. Why don’t you go check if the hospitality tent needs any help?”
Sarah (visibly uncomfortable): “I’ve been in this sport for five years, Tom. My analysis is based on solid data.”
Mike (laughing uncomfortably): “Now, now, let’s not get too worked up. Tom’s just joking around.”
Alex (looking conflicted): “…”
John (observing silently): “…”
Reflecting on the Situation
In this scenario, Sarah is clearly in a tough spot. Despite her expertise and years of experience, she’s met with dismissive attitudes and inappropriate comments. This is a situation many women in male-dominated fields can relate to. Let’s break down the motivations and point of view (POV) for each character:
Sarah:
Motivation: To be taken seriously and contribute her expertise to the team.
POV: Frustrated and hurt by the dismissive attitude, but determined to stand her ground.
Mike:
Motivation: To maintain team harmony and avoid conflict.
POV: Uncomfortable with the situation but hesitant to directly confront Tom’s behaviour.
Tom:
Motivation: To maintain the “boys’ club” atmosphere and assert dominance.
POV: Sees Sarah as an outsider and threat to the traditional male-dominated environment.
Alex:
Motivation: Conflicted between wanting to support Sarah and fear of going against the group.
POV: Recognises the unfairness but unsure how to intervene without risking his own position.
John:
Motivation: To ensure team success and maintain a professional environment.
POV: Observing the interaction and considering how it might affect team dynamics and performance.
Have you ever been in a situation where you felt your contributions were undervalued? How did you handle it?
The Bystander Principle in Male-Dominated Fields
In industries like automotive and motorsports, women often face significant challenges, including sexual harassment and gender-based discrimination. These issues are exacerbated by skewed gender ratios and traditionally masculine cultures. Bystander intervention can be particularly difficult in these environments due to:
Masculine Norms: These norms often discourage men from intervening.
In-Group Bias: Dominant group individuals may be less likely to intervene on behalf of women.
Why These Norms Are Harmful
These norms perpetuate gender inequality and discrimination, limit innovation and diverse perspectives, create hostile work environments, and contribute to the underrepresentation of women in leadership roles.
Long-Term Impacts on Mental Health and Retention of Women
Women in Automotive and Motorsport fields face:
- Increased stress and anxiety from constant exposure to discriminatory behaviour.
- Lower job satisfaction and decreased motivation.
- Higher turnover rates, leading to a loss of valuable skills and expertise.
- Reduced career advancement opportunities.
- Continued gender gaps in these industries.
Underlying Thought Processes for Women in These Environments
Without Active Bystander Culture:
- Constant vigilance and self-doubt.
- Feeling isolated and unsupported.
- Internalising negative stereotypes and biases.
- Hesitancy to speak up or contribute ideas.
- Considering leaving the industry altogether.
With Active Bystander Culture:
Increased sense of safety and support: Effective intervention helps the victim feel less isolated and more supported, increasing the sense of belonging and reducing feelings of helplessness and vulnerability.
Reduced trauma: Timely intervention may prevent or mitigate the severity of a traumatic event, potentially reducing long-term psychological impact, higher job satisfaction and motivation to stay in the industry. Increasing the likelihood of pursuing leadership roles.
Restored faith in humanity: Intervention reinforces the victim’s belief that people care and are willing to help, crucial for their psychological recovery and overall worldview.
Empowerment: Seeing others stand up against injustice empowers the victim to speak up against discrimination for themselves and others in future situations, with greater confidence in their abilities and contributions.
Reduced self-blame: Bystander intervention sends a clear message that the perpetrator’s behaviour is unacceptable.
Types of Interventions
Bystander actions can vary from low to high involvement and immediacy. Examples include privately advising a female colleague that you witnessed what happened and you don’t support the behaviour, or directly confronting the harasser during an incident.
Challenging Masculine Norms
The good news is that society can challenge these norms by:
Comprehensive Policies and Training: Implementing and enforcing robust organisational policies and training programmes.
Encouraging Male Allies: Promoting male allies to speak up against discriminatory behaviour.
Diverse Leadership: Ensuring diverse leadership and representation in these industries.
Education: Raising awareness about the negative impacts of toxic masculinity on both men and women.
Opportunities for Bystander Intervention
The scenario earlier in the pit lane garage highlighted several missed opportunities for bystander intervention:
- Mike could have directly addressed Tom’s inappropriate comment and reinforced Sarah’s expertise.
- Alex could have spoken up in support of Sarah’s strategy, validating her contribution.
- John could have stepped in to remind the team of the value of diverse perspectives and the importance of respect in the workplace.
Effective Bystander Intervention for a Happy Ending
Mike (firmly): “Tom, that’s completely out of line. Sarah is part of our team, and her expertise is invaluable. We don’t tolerate that kind of disrespect here.”
Alex (speaking up): “I agree with Mike. Sarah’s analysis is spot-on. I’ve looked at the data myself, and her two-stop strategy could give us a real edge.”
John (stepping forward): “I couldn’t help but overhear. Tom, your comment was inappropriate and goes against everything our team stands for. We value diversity and respect here. Sarah, please continue with your strategy proposal.”
Tom (looking embarrassed): “I… I’m sorry, Sarah. That was uncalled for. Please, go on with your analysis.”
Sarah (regaining confidence): “Thank you, everyone. As I was saying, the two-stop strategy could significantly reduce our overall race time. Let me show you the data…”
Mike: “Excellent work, Sarah. Let’s dive into the details and see how we can implement this strategy.”
How do you think active intervention changes the dynamics of a team? Have you witnessed or been part of such an intervention?
Circuit Breaker Comments That You Can Practice:
- “That comment/behaviour is inappropriate and makes people uncomfortable. Let’s focus on the task.”
- “We don’t tolerate that kind of language/behaviour here. Please stop.”
- “How would you feel if someone said/did that to your sister/daughter/mother/partner?”
- “That’s not funny. It’s disrespectful and creates a hostile environment.”
- “We value diversity and inclusion here. Your comment/behaviour goes against our values.”
- “I don’t agree with what you just said/did. It’s not acceptable in here.”
- “Let’s take a step back and consider how that comment/behaviour affects our team dynamics.”
Have you ever been a bystander in a difficult situation? Share your stories and let us know how you handled it on our Facebook or Instagram post.
Sources:
https://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/UNELawJl/2004/14.html
https://concove.ac.ns/assets/Building-Bystander-Culture-v2.pdf
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect
https://humanrights.gov.au/our-work/part-4-bystander-interventions-violence-prevention
https://humanrights.gov.au/our-work/publications/theoretical-perspectives-bystander-intervention
https://humanrights.gov.au/sites/default/files/content/sexualharassment/bystander/bystander_june2012.pdf
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1077801215602343
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/01492063231177976
https://performancegarage.com.au/news/womens-impact-on-the-australian-automotive-scene/
https://psychcentral.com/health/bystander-effect
https://www.afp.gov.au/sites/default/files/PDF/Reports/Cultural-Change-Report-2016.pdf
https://www.apa.org/pi/health-equity/bystander-intervention
https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-in-male-dominated-industries-and-occupations/
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00326/full
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/women-automotive-bringing-hustle-male-dominated-industry-megan-walsh
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7082795/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7957849/
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/46559316_Gendered_Performances_in_a_Male-Dominated_Subculture_%27Girl_Racers%27_Car_Modification_and_the_Quest_for_Masculinity
https://www.respectatwork.gov.au/individual/responding-workplace-sexual-harassment/bystander-actions
https://www.simplypsychology.org/bystander-effect.html
https://www.sydney.edu.au/content/dam/corporate/documents/business-school/research/women-work-leadership/One-of-the-Boys-report.pdf
https://www.vichealth.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/Bystander_Final-ReportPhase2Trials.pdf
https://www.wgea.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/WGEA-St-Barbara.pdf
https://www.wiftaustralia.org.au/screenmate1
Bridget Bell is a seasoned motorsport media professional and a skilled mechanic, with over a decade of experience in On-Air Hosting, Event Hosting, Television Presenting and Commentating. Passionate about supporting women in both the industry and motorsport, Bridget volunteers as a mentor and actively champions female representation.
Disclaimer: While due research has been conducted, the views expressed in our articles are those of the author and may not necessarily reflect everyone’s views. If you notice an error, please email quoting the blog article title and an explanation of the error.